Tools / Cash & progression

Which upgrade pays back first?

Compare two purchases with your own income estimates. See the extra cash per minute, the recovery time and whether simply saving would reach your goal sooner.

Compare two upgrades before spending cash

Enter your current income and your estimated income after each upgrade. Compare extra cash per minute, payback time, and time to your target cash amount.

This calculator uses your estimates, not verified game statistics. All fields start empty. K = thousand, M = million, B = billion, T = trillion; Qa and Qi also work.

Your current run
Use cash earned per minute, not your total balance.
Leave empty to calculate from zero saved cash.
The balance you want to reach after paying for an upgrade.
Need to measure your current cash per minute?

Observe cash earned during a timed session without purchases. Enter the earnings and elapsed minutes below.

Must be greater than zero. Half a minute is 0.5.

Upgrade A
Upgrade B

Enter total income after purchase, not just the increase. Test or estimate each upgrade separately from the same starting point.

01 / Get a useful input

Measure before you compare.

  1. Write down your starting cash, active pets and current target.
  2. Let the same setup run for a fixed number of minutes. Avoid purchases, sales and one-off rewards.
  3. Subtract starting cash from ending cash, then divide by the minutes observed.
  4. For after-upgrade income, use a comparable measurement or a clearly identified estimate.
Read the comparison method →

02 / The calculation

Count the extra income.

Extra income = after rate − current rate
Payback time = cost ÷ extra income

Time to your target also includes waiting until you can afford the purchase, subtracts its cost and then uses the new income rate. “Save without an upgrade” keeps your current rate.

The model assumes steady income and an immediate upgrade effect. It does not simulate egg luck or temporary boosts, infer rebirth effects, or plan a chain of later purchases.

03 / Read a result

Same payback. Different arrival time.

Choose Load example above to follow this calculation. All values are hypothetical: 10K cash per minute, 40K saved, and a target balance of 250K. A costs 25K and assumes 12K per minute afterward; B costs 100K and assumes 18K.

These are the calculator’s example inputs, not game statistics.
ChoiceWait to buyCash paybackReach 250K from now
Keep savingNo purchaseNot applicable21 min
Example A0 min12.5 min19.583 min
Example B6 min12.5 min19.889 min

A is affordable now and leaves 15K: the remaining 235K takes 235 ÷ 12 = 19.583 minutes. B takes six minutes to afford, spends the 100K, then needs 250 ÷ 18 = 13.889 more minutes. Both recover their cost from extra income in 12.5 minutes, but A reaches this target slightly earlier.

Try a closer goal

Change only Target cash amount to 50K and compare again. Saving takes 1 minute, A takes 2.917 minutes, and B takes 8.778 minutes. The payback figures stay the same; spending delays the closer goal.

How much income would make B the better choice?

Keep the 250K target and every other example input unchanged. Change only B’s estimated cash per minute after purchase. A still takes 19.583 minutes; saving still takes 21. B still needs six minutes before you can buy it.

Sensitivity check · hypothetical steady income after B
B’s after rateB reaches 250KFastest of the three
16K / min6 + 250 ÷ 16 = 21.625 minA · 19.583 min
18K / min6 + 250 ÷ 18 = 19.889 minA · 19.583 min
20K / min6 + 250 ÷ 20 = 18.5 minB · 18.5 min

B becomes faster than A above a threshold of approximately 18.405K per minute in this scenario: solve 6 + 250 ÷ B’s rate = 235 ÷ 12. That is the decision threshold, rounded to three decimals. A larger income estimate alone is not enough; it must make up for B’s higher cost and the wait to buy it.

If your plausible range is 16K–20K, the evidence does not yet pick a reliable winner. Check a comparable timed reading, or decide whether the possible time saving is worth the uncertainty. If both ends of your range give the same choice, the result is less sensitive to that particular estimate. A training multiplier or a larger clone limit does not supply a measured cash rate.

Keep all rates in cash per minute. To convert a per-second display, multiply by 60. For an observation, divide the cash actually gained by the minutes watched; exclude reward claims, sales and purchases.

Measure cash, handle rounded balances and split changing rates →

Download a blank observation sheet ↓

Before using the result

What if the upgrade does not increase cash?

It has no cash payback in this model. It might still unlock a target or save time. Those benefits need a separate comparison; the calculator does not assign them a made-up cash value.

Does the planner know current game prices?

No. Enter the price shown in your game. Example values demonstrate the calculation and are not prices, pet stats or results from Clone to Steal Eggs.

Are my entries saved or uploaded?

The calculation runs in your browser. This version does not upload or automatically save your entries. Download the comparison if you want to keep it.

CLONE FIELD GUIDE

Find the answer.

Browse guides and useful pages.

↑ ↓ choose · Enter open · Esc closeBrowse all guides →